The company faces tighter restrictions on the $WFC note and may be in jeopardy of violating the net income covenant for FY2016 Q3 when they report in December.
In May of this year the company filed a DEF 14A disclosing that the Founder would continue as President and asked the shareholders for the president to vote their shares via a proxy. After the DEF 14A filing, 4 days later, the founder resigned as President. No DEF 14A was re filed.
There has been suspicious trading in the stock, specifically around the resignation of the company's original auditor resigned over the 4th of July weekend in 2013.
The company has also had some personal selling (insider selling) after some hyped guidance that pumped up the stock price significantly up at the $29 level. (including an appearance on Jim Cramer's Mad Money.)
5 Analysts Participate in Questions and Answer Session Of Conference Call
Yesterday TITAN MACHINERY issued a press release with FY2016 Q1 financials followed by the company's conference call.
Analyst at Feltl Doesn't Participate in Conference Call Q & A but Upgrades Stock Immediately
Local Minnesota Analyst Feltl and Company(Brent R. Rystrom, Director of Research) upgraded Titan Machinery shares with a $20.50 price target without knowing who the new president of the Company will be. The company still has not even filed a 10Q yet.
Felti Upgraded shares and gives a price target that is 46% higher from current levels. (According to Felti company's current market cap under $300 million will grow to over $400 million). Felti says company will go from a ($1.51) loss in FY2015 to a profit of $0.36 for FY2016, but they don't know who the new president will be that will create this dramatic turnaround????? Feltl and Company makes a market in the securities of Titan Machinery
WHAT HAPPEN over a 4 Day period that the CO FOUNDER of the Company changed his mind?
Why would the President of the company resign as president without there being a replacement for his $500,000 a year position?
When interviewed by the press the President said he couldn't comment because the company was in a "Quiet Period" because the company would be reporting FY2016 Q1 financials and after the numbers were released on May 28,2015 (yesterday) the management would then be able to comment.
The company held their conference call yesterday and never commented on why the President decided to step down and the Management never mentioned Who would be replacing him. None of the Analysts on the call cared to ask and no reason was ever disclosed.
It is almost 3 weeks now and Titan Management still has not named a replacement and next Thursday they will have a vacant president seat.
The company reported annual FY2015 financials for the period ending January 31,2015 last month disclosing a loss of ($1.51) per share for the year. 7 months earlier the company had given guidance that they would earn $1.00 per share in that period.
Yesterday FY2016 Q1 financials were disclosed in an 8k and the company reported a loss for the quarter of $(0.29) per share. (As of 11am this morning no 10Q has yet to be filed with SEC)
3 Mutual funds control 42% of shares outstanding and there has been barely any sellers in the stock recently. The month of May 2015 is the smallest average daily volume in the stock (at 100,000 average shares per day for the month) since June 2010.
The company has be closing stores and revenues have declined dramatically.
Why is this company trading at a $300 million market capitalization and why does Felti believe it is worth over $400 million?
Proxy Statement Only 4 days ago Titan Machinery filed a DEF 14 A proxy statement for the upcoming FY2016 annual meeting which is to take place in June. In the proxy disclosure Christenson is disclosed as a board member and president but it is still not clear if shareholders receiving this new proxy will be notified of the sudden resignation in time for the June vote. NO mention of who the new nominee will be for the 9th board seat that will now be vacant.
8K Director Resigns 8 weeks ago another board member since 2003 , James Williams, also announced he will be resigning from the board. That announcement came the same day that management released a preliminary FY2015 warning to the street that the company would lose in excess of $30 million for FY2015.
Mr. Williams is the current Chairman of the Nominating Committee and also a member of the 3 person Audit Committee.
New Auditor=Less Disclosure
In the Spring of 2014 the company filed it's first DEF 14 A using the new auditor Deloitte and Touche. Company stated it no longer was required to disclose the transactions with the outside entity Dealer Sites LLC that management had held a position in because that equity interest had declined to less than 10%.
Although that disclosure was in the spring of 2014, Dealer Sites LLC continued to receive their mailings to the care of Titan's treasurer Ted Christianson., although he supposively held less than 10% of such entity.
Dealer Sites LLC is important because less than 2 years ago TITAN increased their contract with Dealer Sites from $50 million to over $100 million and extended it out to 2028. This is prior to closing in excess of 10 location in that same period. There has been no disclosure as to whether any of the stores that have been closed were Dealer Sites lease locations. Titan is responsible for taxes and maintenance of those properties.
We (TITAN MACHINERY) lease real estate for 24 of our 34 stores from
entities affiliated with Messrs. Meyer, Tony Christianson and/or Peter
Christianson. We lease three dealership sites from Meyer Family Limited
Partnership, for which Mr. Meyer serves as general partner and of which
certain members of Mr. Meyer’s immediate family are limited partners; 18
dealership sites from Dealer Sites, LLC, an entity affiliated by common
ownership with Mr. Meyer and Tony Christianson, who collectively owned 40%
of Dealer Sites, LLC as of January 31, 2007, and for which Ted
Christianson, our Vice President, Finance and Treasurer, serves as president
and Mr. Meyer serves as an officer; the site for our Fargo outlet store
from C.I. Farm Power, an entity affiliated by common ownership with Peter
Christianson; one dealership site from Padre Partnership, an entity affiliated
by common ownership with Peter Christianson, who is also the general partner;
and one dealership site from Landco LLC, an entity affiliated by common
ownership with Peter Christianson and Mr. Meyer."
Hanky Panky Note #4786
TITAN's MANAGEMENT OUTSIDE ENTITY BUYS PROPERTY FOR $1.00.
12 acres
of commercial land for $1.00.
Dealer Sites LLC is the property
ownership company for Titan Machinery, which acquired the property from the
city for $1 and will lease it to its operating company, Titan.
General Counsel/Corp. Compliance Officer/Secretary
Does the corporate Compliance Officer Need to be disclosed in SEC filings as an Officer of the Company? Should his Holdings be disclosed as well? I looked but I couldn't find Steve Noack name. It might be somewhere but I surely didn't find it.
3. List the name and complete street address of all persons conducting
business under the above Assumed Name, OR if an entity, provide the
legal corporate, LLC, or Limited Partnership name and registered office
address:
Titan Machinery Inc.
644 East Beaton Drive
West Fargo, ND 58078
More Suspicious Trading March 2015 After close on March 9th Titan released disappointing warning that year end numbers would be disappointing and the shares were halted after hours. Titan Machinery (NASDAQ: TITN) suspiciously traded down 6% that day while the overall markets were all higher.
I've got to hand it to $GFFNStock (Tom Renna): He's been warning on $TITN for quite awhile http://t.co/Fso3e4laAg Also not a fan of $SSYS — Herb Greenberg (@herbgreenberg) May 24, 2013
Following key words are what caught my eye, especially since these hats are worn by 4 or 5 execs: 3 Brothers, A Son, A Brother-In-Law, COO, Chairman, Founder, Commission, Managing Director of Underwriter, Owner of Construction Company, Unsecured loans, LEASE Arrangements with Top 3 Execs outside Entities, Real Estate Sale between TITN and Top two Execs Outside Entity, Private Jet, Consulting fees, underwriting fees....(oh yeah, the time Chairman went on Mad Money and then sold shares )
A. 10 K Highlights of Weak Fundamentals B. Roddy Boyd Recognizes my Work C.Certain Related Party Transactions D.Insider Selling after Making Hyped Up Projections (missed by a mile) E.Increase Of Authorized Shares F.CNH AMERICA Floor Debt Plan G.Property sold to Entity owned by Top 2 Execs.without disclosure H.Property Ownership Company owned by Top 2 Execs outside entity. I.Brother-in-law Construction Company building multi-million dollars worth of buildings. J.OLD INVENTORY list (108 page document), not sure how if its obsolete yet. K.History of Negative Operational Cash Flow L.Private Jet M.$150 million convertible note disclosure. (using best scenario vs. worse scenario in disclosure) N.Immediate Family Members: commissions, raises, fees, consulting agreements O.Cash Advance Business offering loans to Bad Credit/No Credit borrowers P.Variable Interest on Debt Q.Interest Expense R.The Mystery of brother Ted Christianson disclosure (former CFO, now Treasurer) S.Auditor's History
Titan Machinery (NASDAQ: TITN $21.78) filed a Schedule 14A (Definitive proxy statement) last night with the Securities & Exchange Commission.
Certain Transactions
Described below are
transactions and series of similar transactions that have occurred
during fiscal 2013 to which we were a party or
are a party in which:
•
the amounts involved exceeded or will exceed $120,000; and
•
a director, executive officer, beneficial owner of more than five percent of any class of our voting securities or any
member of their immediate family had or will have a direct or indirect material interest.
As of January 31,
2013, we leased real estate for 48 of our 120 stores from Dealer Sites,
LLC, ("Dealer Sites") an entity in
which a minority position was owned by an entity affiliated with David
Meyer, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, an entity affiliated
with Tony
Christianson, one of our directors, and Peter Christianson, our
President and Chief Operating Officer, and certain of their immediate
family members (collectively the "Related Persons"). The
collective equity ownership of the Related Persons in Dealer Sites was
approximately 30% during the first 11 months of fiscal 2013. Effective
December 31, 2012, the collective ownership
of the Related Persons was reduced to approximately 9%, due to a
purchase and sale of equity interests between certain of the Related
Persons and other unaffiliated owners of Dealer Sites. The Company
also entered into sale-leaseback agreements with Dealer Sites from which
the Company received $1.3 million for the year ended January 31, 2013.
We
also lease one dealership site from C.I. Farm Power Inc., an entity owned by Mr. Peter Christianson.
The
table below states for fiscal 2013 through the end of the respective
lease terms, the aggregate amount of all periodic minimum lease payments
or installments made or due, including
any required or optional payments due at the conclusion of the
respective leases, are as follows:
Lessor
Period
Aggregate
Payments Made
or Due
Dealer Sites, LLC
Fiscal 2013
$
6,899,000
Fiscal 2014, through
January 2028
$
103,047,000
C.I. Farm Power, Inc.
Fiscal 2013
$
144,000
Fiscal 2014, through
July 2013
$
72,000
We
believe the terms of the leases to be commercially reasonable, and are
not any less favorable to us than could be obtained in an arm's length
transaction with an unrelated party.
During fiscal 2013,
Ted Christianson served as our Vice President, Finance and Treasurer
and received total cash compensation of
approximately $333,000 and a restricted stock award of 1,012 shares of
our common stock, with a grant-date fair value of $29,986. Ted
Christianson is the brother of Peter Christianson, our President and
Chief Operating Officer, and of Tony Christianson, a member of our Board
of Directors.
35
During
fiscal 2013, Sam Christianson, the son of Peter Christianson, was an
employee of the Company and received total cash compensation of
approximately $190,000 pursuant to a standard
commission-based plan of compensation that is subject to annual
variation.
Both
of the above identified employees participated in employee benefits
plans and programs available to our other full time employees.
C.I. Construction,
LLC, ("CI") performs construction management services for certain of the
Company's new store construction
projects, shop additions, and existing facilities remodel projects. CI
is owned by Rob Thompson, who is the brother-in-law of Tony
Christianson, a member of our Board of
Directors, and Peter Christianson, a member of our Board of Directors
and our President and Chief Operating Officer. CI is responsible for
developing designs/specifications, drawings, bid packages,
advising on the selection of suppliers and contractors, and overseeing
the construction process. CI is also an authorized reseller of certain
building materials that the Company generally incorporates
into its new construction and certain remodeling projects.
CI
receives a fee equal to 4.5% of the construction costs, excluding
expenditures for certain fixtures and fixed assets that the Company
originates. CI is also reimbursed for the labor
costs of CI's site supervisors and on-site staff, and utilities,
equipment rental, travel, and other direct costs incurred by CI in
performing the services. CI also receives payment as a
reseller of certain building materials used in its construction
projects.
During
fiscal 2013, CI received an aggregate amount of $6.7 million in direct
or indirect payments from the Company for the above construction-related
services and product
resales, as well as reimbursement for other construction-related costs.
We do not believe the terms of any of the transactions and agreements
described above are any less favorable to us than could be
obtained in an arm's length transaction with an unrelated party.
During fiscal 2013,
Cherry Tree Companies, LLC, an entity controlled by Tony Christianson, a
member of our Board of Directors, received
aggregate compensation of $173,000, consisting of a one-time payment of
$113,000 pursuant to compensation paid to the underwriters in our April
2012 convertible note offering and a $5,000
per month payment for consulting services rendered to the Company. We do
not believe the terms of our consulting or underwriter compensation
arrangements with Cherry Tree Companies, LLC were any less
favorable to us than could be obtained in an arm's length transaction
with an unrelated party.
*******If you look below at the
April 2012 DEF Proxy Disclosure and compare it to the 2013 proxy
disclosure above, you'll notice that TITN entered into an additional
$50million worth of lease contracts (bringing total to over $100million)
with the entity Dealer Sites LLC which is an entity that is owned in
part to the top 2 Execs at TITN. What really raises an even bigger Red Flag is that TITN only increased locations owned by Dealer Sites by 2, 46 to 48 locations, but added over $50 million in leases agreements!there was no disclosure of the additional lease arrangements in the 10K filed less than 3 weeks ago. did all these lease agreements get done over the last 3 weeks?
A close
look at C&I Farm Power lease looks fuzzy too. The dates (time
frames) don't add up and the payment has been reduced from (changed) to $216,000 (below '12) down to $72,000 (above '13). Was $144,000 paid to C&I?
2012 DEF14 Proxy Statement
The
table below states for fiscal 2012 through the end of the respective
lease terms, the aggregate amount of all periodic payments or
installments made or due, including any required or
optional payments due at the conclusion of the respective leases, are
as follows:
Lessor
Period
Aggregate
Payments
Made or Due
Dealer Sites, LLC
Fiscal 2012
$
6,196,986
Fiscal 2013, through
January 2027
$
51,424,827
C.I. Farm Power, Inc.
Fiscal 2012
$
144,000
Fiscal 2013, through
July 2013
$
216,000
TITAN SELLS PROPERTY TO DEALER SITES (but there is no SEC disclosure)
Check
out this article i found, it is from July 2011. (2 days before the 2nd quarter
ended).
I can't
find any disclosure of this transaction in any SEC filing though. *****What's most strange about this transaction is that TITAN purchased the Property in May and then turned around and sold it to Dealer Sites two months later for a profit. While all this real estate is trading hands, The Chairman appears on Jim Cramer's Mad Money hyping the stock and then the Chairman and CEO combined to UNLOAD $14million worth of stock. What a Quarter these guys had. (Q2 ending July 31,2011).
This is really too close for
comfort
IMO, considering Dealer Sites LLC is an entity owned in part by TITN top 2
executives. Years ago Dealer Sites was disclosed in TITN SEC documents
as being owned by not only top 2 execs of TITN , but also other family
relationships as well. In Recent disclosure the wording has changed to
only say top 2 execs only have a minority interest and/or less than 10%
interest in other disclosure.
Property ID: 271030010 6340 E. County Road 101, Shakopee Price: $2,450,000 Filing date: 5/31/2011 ******Seller: St. Joseph's Equipment Inc. ********Buyer: Titan Machinery Inc. Property ID: 271030010
The purchase of the property from St Joseph's is in the SEC 2Q FY2011 10Q , but the sale to Dealer Sites LLC is not disclosed.
"On
May 31, 2011, the Company acquired certain assets of St. Joseph
Equipment Inc. The acquired entity consisted of four construction
equipment locations in Shakopee, Hermantown and Elk River, Minnesota,
and La Crosse, Wisconsin. The acquisition establishes the Company’s
first construction equipment store in Wisconsin and allows the Company
to have the exclusive Case Construction contract for the entire state of
Minnesota and 11 counties in western Wisconsin. The acquisition-date
fair value of the total consideration transferred for the dealerships
was $17.0 million."
I'd
like to know if this sale contributed to the income statement for
FY2012 in any way. Wells Fargo raised the $150 million Indenture based
on the FY2012 financial disclosure, but I don't see any record of this
transaction in any SEC disclosure? Why did Wells Fargo do a Convertible Indenture @ $43 a share? Why
did they sell the property anyway? Wouldn't they then have to start
leasing it from Dealer Sites?
TITAN's MANAGEMENT OUTSIDE ENTITY BUYS PROPERTY FOR $1.00.
12 acres
of commercial land for $1.00.
Dealer Sites LLC is the property
ownership company for Titan Machinery, which acquired the property from the
city for $1 and will lease it to its operating company, Titan.
State
of the art (titn) facilities (property is own my Dealer Sites LLC (which is
partially owned by top 2 executives of TITN) and a lot of inventory on the
property is paid for through CNH America Loans. TITN pays interest on loans. I
wonder if CNH is loading up TITN with tractors to help make CNH’s revenue
numbers?
I’d
also be interested in the relationship of the Construction company and Dealer
Sites LLC.
TITAN advertises in an 108 pagedocument. The new Tractors (2013 models) are state of the art (technology). I
wonder why anyone would purchase used equipment that is almost obsolete with all the new products being introduced to market?
10K discloses top 2 Execs both raised annual salaries from $330k to $500k.
Make sure this Nominee gets elected,
Mr. Tony Christianson has been a director since January 2003 and was a founder of Titan Machinery LLC. Since 1981, Mr. Christianson has been the Chairman of Cherry Tree Companies... Considering Cherry Tree did underwriting for the $150 million Convertible Note in 2012.
http://www.cherrytree.com/news/releasearchive/titan_0412.htm
Capital Resources (from 10K)
Our ability to service our debt will depend upon our ability to generate the necessary cash. This will depend on our future acquisition activity, operating performance, general economic conditions, and financial, competitive, business and other factors, some of which are beyond our immediate control. Based on our current operational performance, we believe our cash flow from operations, available cash and available borrowings under the existing credit facilities will adequately provide our liquidity needs for, at a minimum, the next 12 months.
We cannot assure you, however, that our business will generate sufficient cash flow from operations or that future borrowings will be available under the credit facilities with the Wells Fargo Bank Syndicate and CNH Capital in amounts sufficient to allow us to service our indebtedness and to meet our other commitments. If we are unable to generate sufficient cash flow from operations or to obtain sufficient future borrowings, we may be required to seek one or more alternatives such as refinancing or restructuring our indebtedness, selling material assets or operations or seeking to raise additional debt or equity capital. We cannot assure you that we will be able to succeed with one of these alternatives on commercially reasonable terms, if at all. In addition, if we pursue strategic acquisitions, we may require additional equity or debt financing to consummate the transactions, and we cannot assure you that we will succeed in obtaining this financing on favorable terms or at all. If we incur additional indebtedness to finance any of these transactions, this may place increased demands on our cash flow from operations to service the resulting increased debt. Our existing debt agreements contain restrictive covenants that may restrict our ability to adopt any of these alternatives. Any non-compliance by us under the terms of our debt agreements could result in an event of default which, if not cured, could result in the acceleration of our debt.
NOTE 13—CAPITAL STRUCTURE
The Company amended its certificate of incorporation on June 1, 2012, providing the Company with the authority to issue 50,000,000 shares of $0.00001 par value stock, consisting of 45,000,000 shares of common stock and 5,000,000 shares classified as undesignated. Prior to June 1, 2012, the Company had the authority to issue 30,000,000 shares of $0.00001 par value stock, consisting of 25,000,000 shares of common stock and 5,000,000 shares classified as undesignated.
PRIVATE JET
A $500 million market cap company with an interest in a private JET Agreement with Officer:
Your employment will be based at the Company’s headquarters in Fargo, North Dakota. Of course, regular travel will be required in the course of performing your duties and responsibilities as President and Chief Operating Officer. Pursuant to the Company’s applicable policies, this travel may include use of aircraft in which the Company has an ownership interest.
During the year ended January 31, 2013, the Company leased buildings from Dealer Sites, LLC ("Dealer Sites"), an entity in which a minority position was owned by an entity affiliated with David Meyer, the Company's Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, an entity affiliated with Tony Christianson, one of the Company's directors, Peter Christianson, the Company's President and Chief Operating Officer, and other Meyer and Christianson family members. As of January 31, 2013, total related party ownership in Dealer Sites was less than 10%. The Company leased buildings pursuant to 48 different operating lease agreements from Dealer Sites, LLC ("Dealer Sites") and one building pursuant to operating leases from C.I. Farm Power, Inc., a company affiliated with Peter Christianson, as of January 31, 2013. Rent expense for leases with related parties totaled $7.0 million, $6.3 million and $5.3 million for the years ended January 31, 2013, 2012 and 2011, respectively. The leases expire on various dates between July 2013 and January 2028, contain purchase options based on fair values at the time of purchase, and provide that the lessee pay all property taxes, utilities, insurance and all expenses necessary for the general maintenance of the respective buildings.The Company also entered into sale-leaseback agreements with Dealer Sites from which the Company received $1.3 million and $6.8 million for the years ended January 31, 2013 and 2012, respectively.
The Company also leases 84 additional buildings under operating lease agreements with unrelated parties and leases office equipment and vehicles under various operating lease agreements. The leases expire at various dates through January 2028. Rent and lease expense under all operating leases totaled $17.3 million, $13.1 million and $9.8 million during the years ended January 31, 2013, 2012 and 2011, respectively. Certain leases have fluctuating minimum lease payments. The Company recognizes lease expense on a straight-line basis over the expected term of the lease.
Approximate minimum future lease payments are as follows:
Years ending January 31,
Amount
(in thousands)
2014
$ 18,996
2015
17,472
2016
15,388
2017
14,138
2018
13,486
Thereafter
91,312
$ 170,792
The Company utilizes C.I. Construction, an entity owned by the brother-in-law of Peter Christianson and Tony Christianson, to perform construction management services for its building and leasehold improvement projects. Payments to C.I. Construction, which include cost reimbursements of certain building supplies and other construction costs, totaled $6.7 million, $3.2 million and $0.7 million for the years ended January 31, 2013, 2012 and 2011, respectively. During the year ended January 31, 2013, the Company also paid a total of $0.2 million to Cherry Tree & Associates, LLC, an entity affiliated with Tony Christianson, primarily for services related to the Convertible Notes offering.
TITN had $124 million in cash as of Jan.
31,2013. If they didn't receive the $150 indenture last April from Wells
Fargo, would they even be in business today? (It
also helped that the Managing Partner of the underwriter is not only a
founder and a director of TITN, but his brother is the COO of TITN.
TITAN advertises the convertible price in their best case scenario of 3,474,000 shares @ $43.17 , but in my opinion I believe they should also advertise the worse case convertible of 4,184,230 shares @ $35.84 per share.
"The
initial conversion rate for the Notes is 23.1626 shares of Company common stock
per $1,000 principal amount of notes, and is subject to certain adjustments as
set forth in the Indenture".
"Pursuant to the Indenture, the Company has agreed not
to make distributions on its common stock or take any other action that would
result in an adjustment to the conversion rate of the Notes if, following such
adjustment, the conversion rate would exceed 27.8980 shares per $1,000
principal amount of Notes"
IMMEDIATE FAMILY MEMBERS
Immediate
Family Members are Employees of the Company
During
fiscal 2013, Ted Christianson served as our Vice President, Finance and
Treasurer and received total cash compensation of approximately $333,000 and a
restricted stock award of 1,012 shares of our common stock, with a
grant-date fair value of $29,986. Ted Christianson is the brother of Peter
Christianson, our President and Chief Operating Officer, and of Tony
Christianson, a member of our Board of Directors.
During
fiscal 2013, Sam Christianson, the son of Peter Christianson, was an employee
of the Company and received total cash compensation of approximately $190,000
pursuant to a standard commission-based plan of compensation that is subject to
annual variation. Both
of the above identified employees participated in employee benefits plans and
programs available to our other full time employees.
Construction
Management Services
C.I. Construction,
LLC, ("CI") performs construction management services for certain of
the Company's new store construction projects, shop additions, and existing
facilities remodel projects. CI is owned by Rob Thompson, who is the
brother-in-law of Tony Christianson, a member of our Board of Directors, and
Peter Christianson, a member of our Board of Directors and our President and
Chief Operating Officer. CI is responsible for developing
designs/specifications, drawings, bid packages, advising on the selection of
suppliers and contractors, and overseeing the construction process. CI is also
an authorized reseller of certain building materials that the Company generally
incorporates into its new construction and certain remodeling projects. CI
receives a fee equal to 4.5% of the construction costs, excluding expenditures
for certain fixtures and fixed assets that the Company originates. CI is also
reimbursed for the labor costs of CI's site supervisors and on-site staff, and
utilities, equipment rental, travel, and other direct costs incurred by CI in
performing the services. CI also receives payment as a reseller of certain
building materials used in its construction projects. During
fiscal 2013, CI received an aggregate amount of $6.7 million in direct or
indirect payments from the Company for the above construction-related services
and product resales, as well as reimbursement for other construction-related
costs. We do not believe the terms of any of the transactions and agreements
described above are any less favorable to us than could be obtained in an arm's
length transaction with an unrelated party.
Consulting
Agreement
During
fiscal 2013, Cherry Tree Companies, LLC, an entity controlled by Tony
Christianson, a member of our Board of Directors, received aggregate
compensation of $173,000, consisting of a one-time payment of $113,000 pursuant
to compensation paid to the underwriters in our April 2012 convertible note
offering and a $5,000 per month payment for consulting services rendered to the
Company. We do not believe the terms of our consulting or underwriter compensation
arrangements with Cherry Tree Companies, LLC were any less favorable to us than
could be obtained in an arm's length transaction with an unrelated party.
TITN paid nearly $23 million in INTEREST EXPENSE for the year 10K 2013. (that's over $1 a share in servicing debt.)
they
only paid interest on the indenture for quarters 2,3, & 4, because
they borrowed the money approx. april 30th at end of Q1 2013.
vs. FY2012 they spent less than $10 million in interest expense. that's over 125%increase.
the
quarter that ended yesterday Q1 2014 , will have higher interest
expense than Q1 2013 because the interest expense on the indenture will
show up and last yr Q1 this expense wasn't there. Let's say interest
expense for Q1 2014 is the same as Q4 2013, that will be nearly
$8million (conservatively). that will be almost a $0.40 cent share hit
against EPS.
Q1 2013 interest expense was $3.6 million (about $0.17 a share hit on EPS)
MAY 1,2013 TITAN will have first interest payment due on $150million indenture due. That will be an approximate **$5.6 million in interest for the FY2013 2nd Quarter numbers for the period ending July 31,2013 that are due out the first week of September.
** this will be in addition to all other interest payments (Other debts and Floor Plan debt interest payments). This
company is a classic roll up model of weak companies, all looking for
an exit strategy. Roll ups are okay if there is an economy of scale
(critical mass). But this company increases their Selling & General
Administrative Expenses at the almost the same proportion that they
increase sales. SGA increased to $247 million for the year FY2013 up from $194 million in FY2012. that's a 27% increase. Meanwhile, Gross Profit only increased 23% year over year and sales increased over the same period only 32%. (a mere 5 % higher).
On June 9,2011 Chairman David Meyer appeared on Jim Cramer's MAD MONEY
and touted TITAN MACHINERY's future. Thirty days later DAVID MEYER SOLD 300,000 shares @ $27.80 and received
proceeds of $8,340.00.00 and CEO Peter Christianson sold
200,000 shares $27.80 for proceeds of $5.56 million. Weeks later Dealer
Sites LLC, an entity owned by Meyer and the Christianson brothers would
purchase $2.4 million property from Titan Machinery. (and then Titan
would begin to lease that property from Dealer Sites LLC.) There is no
SEC disclosure regarding this transaction that took place 2 days before
the 2nd quarter 2011 closed, I was able to find it in property records
(see link further down).
" We expect our annual net income attributable to common stockholders to
be in the range of $44.1 million to $48.3 million resulting in an
earnings per diluted share range of $2.10 to $2.30.." Three weeks later Peter Christianson sold 50,000 shares of TITN @ $24.52 and received proceeds of $1.2 million.
The underwriter Cherry Tree (owned by director Tony Christianson,
the brother of CEO) raised $150 million indenture offering in April of
2012) followed on June 2012 TITAN gave the following guidance in a press release:
"Net income attributable to
common stockholders is expected to be in the range of $53.8 million to
$58.0 million, resulting in earnings per diluted share range of $2.55 to
$2.75". In July 2012 director Tony Christianson and director Irwin James both sold
shares of TITAN (TITN) in the market place above $30 per share.
CFO (Brother 3) turned Treasurer No Longer in Disclosure
Ted Christianson, there is too much to type about the third brother Ted Christianson. TITAN disclosed he was CFO and then approximately April 11,2011 he was no longer CFO. (NO 8-K filed) In April 2012 he was disclosed as the treasurer of the company in the Indenture disclosure. Titan from time to time discloses his holdings, salaries, fees and relationship to the company since April 2011.
Selling & General Administrative Expenses for FY2013 was $247,000,000.00 Titan leases property from the top executive's (outside entity) properties. CNH Machinery loads up the property with inventory and charges Titan interest on the inventory, called Floor Plan debt (approximately $1 billion). Titan salesman are paid commissions for selling inventory. Law firm and CPA firm needs to get paid to maintain listing as a public company.What is really left for the shareholder?Right now there is about $120 million in cash and approximately $1 billion in debt.
A January 2008 IPO raising approx $60 million.
A Spring 2011 Underwriting approx $60 million.
A Spring 2012 $150 million Indenture.
Company recently approved increasing authorized shares outstanding from 30 million to 50 million.
Management (& Family) Outside Entities make all the money:
on leasing property to TITN.
sales commissions
underwriting fees
selling stock annually
having expenses, maintenance and fees on their outside entities properties paid by TITAN.
Brother-in-law generating millions of dollars worth of construction fees (questionable if its even needed).